No consensus from Hayward leaders for combatting homelessness

Hayward Councilmember Greg Jones said the city
needs an emergency homeless shelter.

HAYWARD CITY COUNCIL | Homelessness in Hayward continues to be a vexing problem for its city council. While the problem exists in the city and primarily in its struggling downtown area, the council struggled to reach a consensus this week for solutions or even initial steps for its city staff to pursue.

“We’re all over the place here,” said Hayward Mayor Barbara Halliday. She acknowledged the range of suggestions from the council Tuesday evening included funding one staff member with a host of duties to serve the homeless to a broader and more collaborative strategy. “What have we accomplished tonight? I’m not sure,” Halliday said.

However, some council members found agreement for the need to fund an emergency homeless shelter. “We need to somehow find a place for these folks,” said Councilmember Greg Jones. The city needs to prioritize funding for a shelter now on their own or find partners, he added. But, most acknowledged the city’s general fund is still reeling from the last recession and allocations for items such as homeless shelters will be difficult to find. In most part, social services typically fall in the realm of the county, but some in Hayward have questioned whether the city’s $250,000 in annual funding for the homeless-related programs is enough or an efficient use of money.

Tuesday’s work session was necessitated, said Hayward City Manager Fran David, because the council lacks of clear path on the issue. “We are not about ending homelessness. It will never happen in my lifetime,” said David. “I am convinced of that.” She added the city can only strive to limit it from occurring in the future. A Hayward Taskforce on Homelessness and Hunger will begin a survey on the number of homeless in the city, said David, using a broader definition similar to the federal government. The survey is in collaboration with Cal State East Bay. In Alameda County, it is estimated more than 4,000 people are homeless, according to a staff report.

Meanwhile, few council members referenced one of the most dramatic factors leading to homelessness, that being unemployment and chronic underemployment. Halliday suggested the city institute a jobs program or volunteer work program in exchange for meal vouchers. She also reluctantly broached the idea of reconstituting shipping containers for small homes. An idea previously mentioned by Councilmember Francisco Zermeno.

The homeless and underprivileged need basic amenities and the opportunity to learn new skills, Zermeno said Tuesday evening. He offered as a small solution to reconfigure buses into showers and bathrooms for the homeless and partner with the city’s array of colleges to create food banks.

In addition, Zermeno said the city could takeover one of the abandoned homes owned by CalTrans on B Street and staff it with a single worker providing a host of services for the city’s homeless. However, in a curious statement reminiscent of Zermeno’s idea in 2013 to feed the homeless with fruit trees on city streets, he said among the services the staffer might simply be sympathy. “Do they need somebody to hug them?” Zermeno said.

“What you described sounded great,” countered Councilmember Al Mendall, “but there’s no human being on the plant that can do all that. That’s 20-30 people by my count, working full-time.” He added, “There’s no money for that.”

While acknowledging the depth of the homelessness problem in Hayward, Mendall said, “Social Services are not a core function for municipalities.” Instead, Hayward should be a partner. “It’s not realistic or sustainable to think that the city will take lead and carry it and be the one that makes things happen.”

7 thoughts on “No consensus from Hayward leaders for combatting homelessness

  1. By MW:

    In regard to solving the homeless problem in Hayward or anywhere else in the Bay area, I am extremely confident that the phonies who pretend to be liberals that heavily infest the Bay area can, and including with the “assistance” of their “experts,” come up with some extremely elaborate and very expensive programs that in the long run will make things much worse.

    In fact, and rather than having the city of Hayward looking at the homeless problem and its homeless problem and attempting to solve it primarily or largely only from a Hayward perspective, I suggest we appoint a board that will try to solve it from an entire East Bay perspective. So let's appoint a board made up of East Bay “experts” on social issues that will include Nate Miley and Nadia Lockyer.


  2. Someone should tell Weird Al that the City of Hayward can't make anything happen without passing the cost onto taxpayers first. So many committees, boards, task forces, meetings and assorted tomfoolery means that it takes forever and a day to get things done. What do you expect from a city who budgets out to the year 2040? Hayward isn't backwards, it is franwards.


  3. Greg Jones was an inept City Manager who almost got fired for his indescretions/sexual liaisons. He is just taking up space on City Council. If it hadn't have been for Fire & Police Unions/Associations, he wouldn't have been elected. Don't be fooled in 2016. Jones hasn't accomplished anything,. Its time to get rid of him. Time for that oddball to start packing. Go plug Realty World somewhere else and stop using city resources to build your client list. Fiscal frugality dissappears from Greg's radar whenever Police & Fire contracts come up.


  4. Most of Council could care less about the homeless. They follow Fran's lead about the outdoor camping ordinance, food dispensing in public areas and lack of public toilets. If they fired Fran David, they could almost double the $250,000 they put aside for homeless related programs. At least the homeless can hang out at the new 90 million dollar library when it opens. There will be plenty of bathrooms there.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s