Hayward may ask voters to allow non-citizens to serve on boards

Hayward voters may be asked this November to amend its City Charter and allow non-citizens to serve on city boards and commissions.

Hayward beatThe Hayward City Council unanimously voted to move forward the proposal on Tuesday night by directing staff to begin an analysis for placing the proposed charter amendment on the Nov. 3 ballot.

The decision by the council to formally place the measure on the ballot would have to come sometime before the end of July in order to qualify for the November election.

Hayward’s City Charter, its guiding governmental document, states those eligible for appointment to city boards and commission must a “qualified elector for the city.”

The proposed amendment, offered by the city manager, city attorney, and city clerk, according to a staff report, would eliminate “qualified elector” and replace it with language extending service on boards and commission to all residents of Hayward, regardless of immigration status.

The impetus for the change, according to the city administration, is a consistent lack of qualified candidates for its boards and commissions. Several candidates have been turned away because they are not citizens, according to the staff report.

“There is recognition, however, that U.S. citizenship inhibits the Council’s ability to recruit among Hayward’s larger and more diverse community. Hayward residents who are not U.S. citizens are not necessarily less committed to serving the interests of the community than Hayward residents who are U.S. citizens and registered voters,” staff wrote.

Hayward is one of the most ethnically-diverse cities in the East Bay, touting a Latino population of roughly 40 percent. In addition, up until the last two years, during which vocal progressive activism has risen to prominence, Hayward, however, has long suffered from voter and political apathy.

Hayward Mayor Barbara Halliday said the proposal makes good on a commitment made by the city following a recommendation offered in 2017 by its community task on race that called for a more inclusive city. “I think this speaks to that commitment,” Halliday said of the proposed charter amendment.

Councilmember Aisha Wahab questioned the origins of the charter amendment proposal, saying she had only heard of the proposal after reading about it in the latest agenda.

“I didn’t know where this was coming from,” Wahab added. “We have zero staff time for housing, but we have three city officers with time for a ballot measure.”

City Manager Kelly McAdoo conceded it is a “bit unusual” for staff to bring up forth a proposal absent the council’s direction. Halliday argued support for allowing non-citizens to serve on board and commissions may not have been specifically verbalized, but has existed in the council’s periphery for several years.

The potential addition of this measures and other city-approved measures on the November ballot will not add much to the cost of Hayward’s election, which will be somewhere in excess of $300,000, according to the city clerk. Hayward’s ballot in the fall already includes an at-large election for four seats on the City Council.

“It’s very unclear how much the cost is,” Wahab said, noting the proposed ballot measure may be controversial for some voters.

Councilmember Al Mendall also questioned the lack of specifics when it comes to the cost of the proposed charter amendment and the election in general, urging staff to provide concrete numbers when the proposal is brought back to the council.

*This article was updated to include comments from Tuesday night’s council meeting.




Interviews for appts start soon. Could delay to January if wins at the ballot.

QUestion the

Can only speak to Hayward, not to counties, state

Cost for ballot?
Due to covid will be different registar will be increased costs.
about $300,000
Ballot measure will increase rate, specifically the printing, translation and mailing in voter guide.

Mendall want more specifics on costs when it comes back.



I get the spirit of this,”
I want the cit

10 thoughts on “Hayward may ask voters to allow non-citizens to serve on boards

  1. Whoa holdup. Staff is claiming that the community of noncitizens in Hayward is larger and more diverse than the community of U.S citizens in Hayward? Is this for real?


  2. “Hayward, however, has long suffered from voter and political apathy.” It’s not apathy, people in Hayward perceive City Hall as a deeply leftist corrupted fraud ruled by a one party mob of intellectual midgets. Hayward is a crime ridden super-weird 3rd world country ruled by despots, egomaniacs and greedy hypocrites. Allowing illegal aliens into the government just adds another layer of anti-America idiocy, par for the course in a debauched leftist dystopia.


  3. With a proposal like this, the Council and City Administration are demonstrating that they themselves are not qualified to hold the positions they do. In fact, they’re demonstrating that they’re not even qualified to be citizens, as it is the responsibility of a US citizen to abide by Federal laws. They not only ignore Federal law, they flagrantly flaunt it.


  4. I am curious what is it for the City Manager, City Ckerk and City Attorny? Why would they consider allowing non-citizens to hold office on City Boards? I remember that a couple of years ago San Leandro wanted to fly the “Chinese” flag over City Hall because in their opinion it was “good for business” this was shot down as I hope this ridiculous proposal will be.


  5. What the hell wrong with you people a non-citizen on the board of Hayward California hell next they’ll be running for mayor next to be running for governor next every running for president whoever came up with that idea need to be fired immediately


  6. That will be a big NO, on my ballot. I find it very offensive for this Council to even suggest.


  7. “A consistent lack of qualified candidates”…qualified candidates being those who toe the Council members’ agenda. Of course you’re not going to find a dozen of these candidates in an electorate of what, a couple of hundred thousand. So sure, let’s appoint noncitizens. Will they even have to be legal? Or will ICE be making regular visits to our commission meetings? Won’t it be a Hayward hoot when Fox News leads with Sanctuary City Commissioners deported!?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s