Lai-Bitker asks Health District for $2 million to keep ER open


By Steven Tavares
The Citizen

Alameda County Board of Supervisors President Alice Lai-Bitker, in a letter to the Eden Township Healthcare District, has asked for $2 million to keep the emergency room at San Leandro Hospital open until June of next year, The Citizen has learned.

The letter, sent yesterday to members of the five-member board, may be yet another shift in strategy to keep the hospital open after Sutter Health announced it would cease services at the facility Sept. 30.

Lai-Bitker’s Chief of Staff Shawn Wilson said the short-term goal is to keep emergency room services open while local officials can secure a long-term deal.

A week ago, Lai-Bitker appeared to favor a “hybrid model” of rehab, surgical and ER services at San Leandro Hospital. The Interim Director of the Alameda County Health Services Alex Briscoe indicated such a plan would need between $3.5 million to $7 million annually to run and could possibly entail subsidies from Sutter Health, the Eden Township Healthcare District, Alameda County and the city of San Leandro, yet two of those entities are unlikely to contribute to such a plan.

San Leandro Mayor Tony Santos said, “There is no way we can participate in spending any money on the ER.” Earlier in the day, Santos received sobering news the state plans to borrow redevelopment and specific tax dollars from municipalities to balance its budget.

“I don’t know if he’s the only person who believes this,” said Wilson, “but I don’t think he should close a chapter before it starts. This is a crucial time for keeping the hospital open.”

At Monday’s city council meeting, Santos also said Sutter officials have told him they will not contribute to a hybrid model at San Leandro Hospital, but confirmed the Township Board indicated to him a willingness to make a partial contribution to the hospital cause.

Wilson believes the onus is on the board to help monetarily saying, “The Eden health care board is the entity that put us in this position.”

Santos reiterated what is becoming a common refrain at city hall that the hospital problem is a county issue and not solely San Leandro’s, in addition to calling for a district-wide ballot measure next year. He also told council members Monday night the hospital, at this time, likely has no possible suitors. “There really are not any hospital groups coming forward with the idea of taking over for Sutter,” he said.

Despite local political infighting and a tenuous economy, Wilson believes there is still hope for a solution, “There’s options,” he said, “Even with the situation within in the state, I don’t want people to think nothing can be done.”

Categories: Eden Township, S.L. City Council, S.L. Hospital, Shawn Wilson, Sutter, Tony Santos

3 replies

  1. What about Prime Healthcare?? They still want to run the hospital! That there are no “suitors” is a falsity.


  2. The Mayor indeed continues to spread misinformation. He knows that Prime Healthcare is a “hospital group coming forward with the idea of taking over for Sutter”. Is Mayor Santos confused, or intentionally lying on behalf of Sutter Health? He assisted in the ceremonial groundbreaking for the Sutter Castro Valley new hospital construction; this suggests a distressing answer to that question.

    As far as Supervisor Lai-Bitker's actions here, I'd like to understand why the Healthcare District should give $2 million to Sutter Health, a corporation which has officially told the Eden Healthcare District Directors that they don't give a damn what the Directors or the citizens of the District think regarding the future of SLH, preventing a private offer to maintain current services from being considered. It's pretty astonishing that Sutter got the President of the County Board of Supervisors to do their thug work in public; have no doubt that this is Sutter laundering their demands through San Leandro's Supervisor. Sutter Health is essentially saying “Hand us $2 million or we slit the throat of the Hospital”.

    From the point of view of the Eden District contributing to Sutter's bottom line, isn't it enough that the District purchased SLH for $35 million in 2004, and might well have allowed Sutter to take it for free in 2009?


  3. Also, it is understood that a part of Lai-Bitker's proposal is that the $2 million would only keep the Emergency Room and other services at SLH open until….wait for it….June 2010.

    What is significant about that? Next June is the primary election in which Lai-Bitker will likely face a challenge. So, in essence, Alice says to the Healthcare District Board: “Help me keep SLH limping along by bribing Sutter until I can get re-elected; then Sutter and perhaps the County will kill services.”

    Hey, Alice: The primary problem here is one of healthcare needs, not your re-election status.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: