Santos Joins the Fight


The Citizen

HAYWARD, Calif. – San Leandro Mayor Tony Santos made his most forceful public plea yet to save San Leandro Hospital and its ER. Speaking to the Eden Township Healthcare District Board of Directors Wednesday night, Santos pointedly called for the facility to remain open.

“The people of San Leandro are united on this issue and I stand firmly with them offering hope and demand that the facility remain open along the the ER,” said Santos.

In the past six months, many in the community have criticized the mayor’s perceived lack of involvement on the issue. While maintaining he has been working on the issue for over two years, his public comments since June have appeared to some as indifference and at times mirroring Sutter talking points, making Wednesday’s statements without any equivocation the more surprising, although he later disagreed his position has changed.

“I stand committed to work with you and all other interested parties to find a way to insure everyone in the district has access to quality hospital services,” said Santos. He told The Citizen later, the impetus for his more forceful comments came from a decision last week by the Alameda County Medical Center (ACMC) to not apply for a license to operate emergency room services at San Leandro Hospital. “To be quite blunt, I am upset at ACMC,” said Santos. “If you say you’re going to do something, you should do it.”

If Sutter’s claim to purchase San Leandro Hospital is granted by the Districit or the courts, it would then lease the property to ACMC to run the hospital as an acute rehabilitation facility without emergency room services. Santos, who is running for re-election in 2010, has backed a “hybrid” plan to operate the hospital as an acute rehab, surgical center and emergency room facility, but made no reference to it Wednesday night. The public exclusion of any alternative proposal for San Leandro Hospital by the mayor is telling and points to a breakdown in already tenuous negotiations between Sutter, ACMC and the District.

Santos’ comments coupled with Eden Healthcare Director Dr. Vin Sawhney’s attempt to fire the District’s legal counsel Wednesday point to a new path by supporters of the hospital involving the courts and the legality of the 2007 Memorandum of Understanding between Sutter and the District. Director Carole Rogers said she has received advice from three separate law firms confirming her belief the agreement can be challenged in court.

Mention of District Chair Dr. Rajendra Ratnesar’s open letter last week became combustible as some speakers called for his resignation and again raised doubts of his impartiality as a boardmember and employee of Sutter. The letter was criticized for fomenting what many believe is a non-existent split among communities.

“I think it unwise to try and pit people against each other in the two communities of Castro Valley and San Leandro,” said state Sen. Ellen Corbett. “I have not seen that at any of the discussions at any of the public meetings that you have held. People are supportive of keeping both hospitals open.”

Representatives for the California Nurses Association, the Save San Leandro Coalition and San Leandro City Councilman Jim Prola called for the resignation of Ratnesar and its legal counsel. “It is imperative and a matter of life and death for our residents to keep San Leandro Hospital as a acute care hospital with an ER,” said Prola. “In order to do that you need to get more aggressive with Sutter and in order to do that you need a new board president and a new attorney to give you advice.”
>>>Effectiveness of Local Pols has been Hit and Miss, Oct. 5, 2009.
>>>The Slowly Disappearing City Council, Aug. 28, 2009.
>>>Santos: Hospital’s losses partly from Doctor’s Private Practices, Aug. 6, 2009
>>>Enabled by Local Government; Sutter Holds the Cards, July 16, 2009.
>>>GRAPHIC: With Hospital on the Verge of Closing, Where’s Tony Santos?, June 16, 2009.
>>>Where in the World is Tony Santos?, June 9, 2009.
>>>Santos Takes Timeout to Speak; Defend Self, June 1, 2009.
>>>Q&A with Mayor Tony Santos, June 1, 2009.


4 thoughts on “Santos Joins the Fight

  1. Why not have the board get the F.B.I. involved? The crime is using bogus numbers(overcharging the uninsured) to close an ER which effects the lives of 120,000 people from East Oakland and San Leandro. That by any stretch of the imagination a very serious crime. Like a huricane blowing through a community, Hurricane Sutter is ruining lives and even property. The pain and suffering is already happening. How many seniors are seriously worrying about what will happen to them as they get older and without a doubt more fraile, with serious health problems. And how much will it downgrade property values in the area? If this isn't a high crime , I don't know what is?


  2. If Santos is joining the fight to save the hospital, what took him so long?

    He has mismanaged this issue from day one. He repeated Sutter's lies. He continues to defend Sutter when reporters aren't around and is highly critical of Rogers and Sawhney. He claimed that protesting Sutter's plans at San Leandro Hospital would cause Sutter to back out of rebuilding Eden Hospital and we would lose both hospitals.

    Santos has shown zero leadership on the hospital.


  3. If Mayor Santos has joined the fight on the public's behalf, why has he been lobbying community leaders in recent days to keep Craig Cannizzo as the District's legal counsel? Cannizzo has repeatedly said that Santos' proposed hybrid services outcome is, essentially, not legally possible.

    In fact, why would the Mayor concern himself at all over the District's decision about its legal strategies? Isn't that very strange?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s