EBMUD Director To Former Opponent: You Ain’t A Ute!

By Steven Tavares

The recently re-elected board member for the East Bay Municipal Utility District is protesting the appointment of his election opponent to Castro Valley’s quasi-governmental advisory committee.

Questions over Matt Turner’s
resume holds up pick for
Castro Valley MAC.

Frank Mellon easily beat Matt Turner last November with nearly two-thirds supports, but Tuesday he furnished the Alameda County Board of Supervisors with a memo urging them to reconsider appointing his one-time rival to the Castro Valley Municipal Action Committee.

Mellon says Turner lied about the breadth of his experience at the University of Utah and questioned his resume as a “wilderness EMT” saying there is no designation in California. “This is a question of ethics and responsibility,” Mellon told the Board of Supervisors Tuesday morning,adding, “This is not a vendetta.”

On Turner’s campaign web site for the EBMUD board, he does not explicitly say he graduated from Utah, but obliquely references time at unidentified schools. “Matt received a broad-based higher education at colleges and universities across the country and internationally while working in the construction trades to support himself, eventually becoming a Wilderness EMT teaching state-of-the-art patient recovery, care and transport,” Turner says in his biography.

Turner defended himself before the board with numerous EMT certificates in tow along with transcripts from Utah. He refuted ever referring to himself as a wilderness EMT, although he stated years of similar experience in Mexico.

The appointment of Turner was included on Tuesday’s agenda until Mellon raised concerns about the candidate’s character. The board of supervisors announced during its regular session today it would postpone approval of Turner until a later date while it investigated Mellon’s claims. Miley said he had been alerted to Mellon’s claims over a week ago, but had yet to make inquiries with Turner.

Mellon also said Turner had failed to file a campaign finance report with Fair Political Practice Commission earlier this year. Turner told the board, the FPPC had advise him the filing was held up because of a missing signatures, which he said would be ammended this week.

Appointment to the Castro Valley MAC is practically the most important political position in the unincorporated town. It acts similar to a city council, but without tangible power and reports directly to Supervisor Nate Miley, who represents Castro Valley at the county level.

UPDATE: Reporting from Tuesday’s meeting was added to this article. 4/14/11, 2:30 p.m.

Categories: Alameda County Board, Castro Valley, election, Frank Mellon, Matt Turner, Nate Miley

1 reply

  1. (Yes, I am back and no I wasn't out servicing truckers on Highway 5.)

    The county really does a bad job updating their web site…that said…

    This guy is a weasel. His whole campaign against Mellon, who I've known and trusted for almost 25 years, was about misleading and slander. Wilderness EMT? He's the ONLY person applying for the council? Patch reports that Turner was ASKED to take the job by Miley's office.

    Mr. Turner was endorsed in 2010 by “Alameda County District 4 Supervisor Nate Miley's Chief of Staff Seth Kaplan.” This seems to be a conflict of interest.

    Mr. Turner should have corrected his endorsement page when he said he was endorsed by “Castro Valley School District Director Gael Treible.” Gael Treible is made to sound like she's on the school board when in fact, respectfully, she's the districts Director of Business Services (a paid, non-elected job).

    It's like someone saying they are a “County Manager.”

    His site says “He believes good governance requires open communication…”

    So Mr. Turner should PROBABLY come clean with misleading folks and reveal how he came to being considered for appointment. He should PROBABLY also fight his battle alone and not with the help of MAC board member Marc Crawford.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: