The Poor And Hungry Could Face Limited Access To Free Food Vendors In Hayward

HAYWARD CITY COUNCIL//HOMELESS | Charitable groups that feed the poor in Hayward may soon be required to gain city approval and secure costly food handling permits from the Alameda County Health Department. Some Hayward downtown businesses and city officials say the free food sharing events at downtown city parks often feature excess litter and promote an unsafe environment.

A draft ordinance to be discussed by the Hayward City Council Tuesday night, however, does not address either issue. A second ordinance would limit the use of city parks between sunset and sunrise, according to a staff report released Tuesday. If approved next Oct. 15, both ordinances would be limited to a one-year pilot program.

Sara Lamnin, a longtime advocate for the poor in Hayward says neither proposed ordinance takes into account resident’s concern for safety and cleanliness in the downtown areas. “These issues generally do not occur during meal program operations,” she said. “Instead, a centralized resource, recovery, and re-engagement center can facilitate connections to food, shelter, counseling, and services as well as provide opportunities for those in need to use their skills though productive engagement.” There is also fear the potentially onerous permitting process could make it more difficult for free food sharing vendors to feed the poor.

A changing economic infrastructure in Hayward, along with the extended recession, has stymied the city’s downtown center from gaining any forward momentum. The public perception of rising crime in Hayward along with the appearance of the poor lining up for free food events at Portuguese Park Giuliani Plaza, Newman Park, Library Park, and City Hall Plaza, may not exactly promote economic vitality, some members of the business community believe. A second, somewhat unrelated ordinance to be heard Tuesday also uses the rubric of public safety in hopes of abating constant property-related nuisance violations.

According to March 2013 city staff report, 6-12 food sharing operations have been identified in Hayward. Combined they serve 50-100 people daily. Seven months later, the strategy to limit use of the city parks, while ignoring the underlining reasons for the events to exist was first broached Mar. 5 by Councilmember Greg Jones. “I just want to recognize the monopolization, frankly, of a public space for a specific use,” Jones said. “That space is available to the community, not just to one particular user. When we allow that to happen we need to be careful with that because we are precluding others in the community, perhaps, from enjoying that public space.”

Later in the same Mar. 5 council meeting, Mayor Michael Sweeney had sharp words for the presence of the food sharing groups in Hayward. The comments shocked some homeless advocates for being insensitive. “I don’t mean to be a little difficult, but it seems to me if folks in Castro Valley want to feed homeless folks, maybe they should do it in Castro Valley,” said Sweeney. “I don’t know why Hayward deserves that privilege. It seems to me that if people in Castro Valley want to open up their front yard or their home in Castro Valley public spaces, that’s something they should look to do.”

5 thoughts on “The Poor And Hungry Could Face Limited Access To Free Food Vendors In Hayward

  1. Guess they should take down the Heart of the Bay sign,
    seems very heartless to me. Backhanded way to rid
    the city of homeless folks. Pathetic abuse of power!


  2. People should not be fed outside like animals with no restroom facilities. The churches in the area need to step up like they have done in South Hayward. There is not going to be any money from DC or Sacramento to open a needed center in North Hayward.


  3. To Dr. Jones

    How does feeding the poor exclude others from using the park. Is the general public excluded when other groups, including families use the park or is the bias only applicable to people who need a meal?


  4. Thanks goodness Sweeney will be gone soon. Any of the candidates will be more sensitive to the needs of poor than he has ever been. Surprising since he heads a program helping poor seniors. He does not believe in his own program. I have stopped donating to Spectrum since he took over and encourage all my friends to do the same.


  5. Dear Mr. Tavares: Thank you for your coverage of this important issue. Just a point of clarification, something that was in the staff report but not mentioned in your article, is that there are several indoor food distribution locations already in operation in and around Hayward. Many of these locations — including Salvation Army, South Hayward Parish, Bridge of Faith, Meals on Wheels and others — receive city funding to provide food to hungry people in Hayward. It may help your readers to include that clarifying information in your article, to help avoid any unnecessary misunderstanding about the status of food distribution services to needy people in Hayward. Thanks again for your attention to this issue.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s