Alameda birther starts fourth petition to recall councilman

An Alameda resident, who as a candidate for the state legislature, questioned whether his opponent, Assemblymember Rob Bonta, is a U.S. citizenship, and then unsuccessfully attempted six total recall petitions against two Alameda councilmembers in the past year, has launched a seventh.

In the wake of an Alameda County grand jury report last month that, among its findings, said Alameda Councilmembers Jim Oddie and Malia Vella violated the City Charter’s council interference rules, Steve Slauson filed a petition with the city clerk’s office last week to begin the process of collecting almost 10,000 valid signatures for a recall of Oddie.

Oddie Jim head shot

It is the fourth time Oddie has been served by Slauson for his involvement in the city hall scandal that involved allegations by former city manager Jill Keimach that Oddie and Vella attempted to interfere in her selection of a new fire chief. None of the three previous attempts came close to securing enough signatures to qualify for a recall election.

Oddie was served with the latest recall petition prior to last Tuesday’s council meeting. Later, during public comment, Slauson demanded Oddie and Vella resign from the council. “The grand jury report was very explicit. Two councilmembers damaged the people of Alameda and caused irreparable damage to the city of Alameda,” he said. “There is only one way for you to square the pot with the people of Alameda. Resign. That demand is made for your resignation tonight.”

Like other recalls attempted by Slauson, the reason is a vaguely-worded reference to Oddie’s involvement in the “Keimach matter.” The same sentence has been used for three other unsuccessful recall petitions against Vella.

The recent grand jury report is the second independent investigation to find Oddie violated a charter provision that prohibits elected officials from interfering with the duties of the city manager. The primary reason being a letter of recommendation Oddie wrote to Keimach while using city letterhead. An independent investigations the city last year was also troubled by charter’s lack of clarity and urged the city to make amendments soon. There has been much less consensus on Vella’s role in the matter.

Vella Malia

When asked why he did not focus on Oddie’s recall, instead of being sidetracked by another for Vella, Slauson did not have a reason. He added, that Oddie caused a $1 million settlement with Keimach and was one of the people who approved the “ordinance to screw landlords.”

“He is a Bonta lackey and I think Oddie only serves special interests,” said Slauson. Oddie is Bonta’s former assembly district director.

Oddie said he did not want to respond to questions about the latest recall, but said in a statement: “I am focused on championing the affordable housing, senior, and public safety services Alamedans elected me to advocate for—and my priority is to continue serving those needs.  The voters will have another opportunity to judge my record in November 2020.  In the meantime, as for the latest maneuver by my opponents, this is a waste of taxpayer dollars and politics as usual.”

Meanwhile, Slauson’s effort to petition Vella’s recall earlier this year never panned out, he said in an interview. “It’s dead,” he added, because of winter rains and a signature-gathering operation running at the same time for Alameda’s Measure A special election initiative to block the city from zoning a property at Crab Cove for a senior and homeless respite center.

Vella’s pregnancy earlier this year, also made for poor optics, said Slauson. “We didn’t want to cause a miscarriage,” Vella gave birth in late May.

“I call bullshit,” Vella told the East Bay Citizen. “Nobody wanted to sign his petition.”

8 thoughts on “Alameda birther starts fourth petition to recall councilman

  1. Shame on them for what? As far as I could piece together from this article, the violation was committed by Oddie and not Vella, and it was for writing a letter of recommendation. Mr. Oddie actually received prior approval from Ms. Keimach to submit his letter, and then later he offered to retract his letter but she refused. Then, when all this came to a boil, Ms. Keimach changed her story.


  2. Gary Dumlao, is that you? After this “rent control business” started, how come the number of rental units went up?


  3. There were no new facts in the Grand Jury Report. Reminds me of what Jim Comey did to Hillary, wagged their finger but ultimately found no basis for action. Oddie wrote a letter of recommendation which apparently violated a vague portion of the City Charter, which the independent investigator said likely was at odds with his 1st Amendment rights. Nobody has pointed to any misdeeds by Vella. All these two council members do is fight for regular Alamedans on a regular basis. They support housing solutions for the poor, give of their time for numerous causes from supporting FAAS to Alameda Point Collaborative, to the new Wellness Center. I would say the Ms. Keimach’s spurious accusations have cost the city dearly more so than actions taken by these two Council members.


  4. City of Alameda
    Has killed the mom and pop landlourds business I would bet there is less rental units now then when they started this rent controll money business why dont they tell the turth about the numbers


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s